Page 68 - Acrobat J Trad-21-3-2566
P. 68

J Thai Trad Alt Med                                    Vol. 21  No. 3  Sep-Dec  2023  551





                                    p-value     < 0.001 *†  < 0.001 *†   0.019 *‡    0.002 *‡  0.012 *‡  < 0.001 *‡  < 0.001 *†  0.625 ‡





                                       No symptom   103 (39.4)   134 (51.3)   145 (55.6)   91 (34.9)   177 (67.8)   34 (13.0)   32 (12.3)   226 (86.5)




                                Control group §  (n = 261)   Worsen   1 (0.4)   3 (1.2)   4 (1.5)   0 (0.0)   1 (0.4)   1 (0.4)   1 (0.4)   3 (1.2)


                                       No change   132 (50.6)   88 (33.7)   97 (37.2)   160 (61.3)   73 (28.0)   209 (80.1)   167 (63.9)   31 (11.9)





                                       Improved   25 (9.6)   36 (13.8)   15 (5.7)   10 (3.8)   10 (3.8)   17 (6.5)   61 (23.4)   1 (0.4)




                                    p-value      < 0.001 *†    < 0.001 *†    < 0.001 *†    0.001 *†    < 0.001 *‡    < 0.001 *†    < 0.001 *†    0.375 ‡
                            Effect of treatment on Lom-Jub-Pong-Hang-Kao symptoms compared within group





                                       No symptom   113 (40.8)   137 (49.5)   134 (48.4)   84 (30.3)   175 (63.2)   29 (10.5)   46 (16.6)   242 (87.4)



                                Experimental group §    (n = 277)   Worsen   No change   0 (0.0)   127 (45.8)   0 (0.0)   91 (32.8)   1 (0.4)   97 (35.0)   9 (3.2)   152 (54.9)   0 (0.0)   88 (31.8)   0 (0.0)   213 (76.9)   0 (0.0)   159 (57.4)   1 (0.4)   30 (10.8)











                                       Improved   37 (13.4)   49 (17.7)   45 (16.2)   32 (11.6)   35 (12.6)   72 (26.0)
                                                                  14 (5.0)   4 (1.4)  * p < 0.05,  † McNemar test,  ‡ Binomial test,  § Show as frequency (%)





                                           Pain point on 1 st  knee   Pain point on 2 nd  knee   Pain point on 3 rd  knee   Patellar tendon stiffness   Limited knee flexion




                            Table 3   Symptoms         pressure points   pressure points   pressure points   Knee bent   Clicking sound   Knee deformity
   63   64   65   66   67   68   69   70   71   72   73